Sharing rx 500 series hash rates for several cards.

specialbkh

I'm going to report in this discussion every card I try.

Recently, I tried two cards.

Rx 580 8g Sapphire Nitro+ : Hynix
-> ori : 22mh/s (17.4.3) 140w
-> mod : 27mh/s (17.4.3) 86w

Rx 580 8g Gigabyte Aorus : Samsung
-> ori : 24mh/s (17.4.3) 135w
-> mod : 28mh/s (17.4.3) 77w

Today, I'm going to try out

Rx 580 4g Sapphire Nitro+
Rx 570 4g MSI twin frozr

Hashfire

provide us rx570 4g hashrates both stock and moded ones.. and how much cost diff in 470 4g and 570 4g? thanx for sharing details

vmining

Are the watts at wall or gpu-z?

maskmoataz

any update for MSI AMD Radeon RX 580 GAMING X 8G ? , how much hash rate and power consume ?

Wolf0

These MSI RX 480 Gaming X are awesome - not sure if it's better binning, or I got lucky - but I have one happily mining at 28.8 - 29.0... at 0.825V on core.

specialbkh

- they are gpu-z watts. I will get watt measuring tool soon.
- I had issue with my current running rigs. sorry for delay but gonna test 570 4g and 580 4g in few hours.

hamba

Wolf0 said:

These MSI RX 480 Gaming X are awesome - not sure if it's better binning, or I got lucky - but I have one happily mining at 28.8 - 29.0... at 0.825V on core.

Sounds great , almost like my 470 4gb nitro sapphire hynix on 8.5

What memory does the msi one have ? And I suppose you meant 580 instead of 480 ?

specialbkh said:

- they are gpu-z watts. I will get watt measuring tool soon.
- I had issue with my current running rigs. sorry for delay but gonna test 570 4g and 580 4g in few hours.

Cheers for the reports , good read.

Wolf0

I did mean 580 - but I'm going to play with it more, I'm sure she'll go lower on volts.

hamba

Wolf0 said:

I did mean 580 - but I'm going to play with it more, I'm sure she'll go lower on volts.

Is it the XTR or XTX one?

Also what memory chip does it have?

And sounds good that they go as low as 4xx series , might pick some up then.

EpicNod

how do exactly do you calculate the power?

leelaam13

Rx 580 8g Sapphire Nitro+ : Hynix
-> mod : 27mh/s (17.4.3) 86w

I'm getting 27,2mh/s - 69w on MSI RX570 Gaming X, your rx 580 very slow

hamba

leelaam13 said:

Rx 580 8g Sapphire Nitro+ : Hynix
-> mod : 27mh/s (17.4.3) 86w

I'm getting 27,2mh/s - 69w on MSI RX570 Gaming X, your rx 580 very slow

How much memory and which brand on the rx570 msi ?

specialbkh

Yes, rx 580 8g sapphire nitro+ seems slow.
I'm having issue flashing MSI rx570 4g gaming X card.

specialbkh

MSI rx 570 4g gaming x
ori : 22mh/s
mod : 28mh/s

Sapphire rx 580 4g pulse
ori : 24mh/s (factory overclocked)
mod : 28mh/s

I will do more test on rx 580 4g nitro+ today

Overcon

So are they faster or slower than the 480's?

specialbkh

rx580s seems slower thans rx480s
I recommend buying rx570s

Konomi

I got the Rx 570 4g Sapphire Nitro (Hynix) with 24.5mh/s on original bios. I don't know how to mod the bios since the timing look different than my 470/480 (bunch of number like 3251216, not 1500-2000)

Anyway, any of you able to patch 6 gpu on the new driver for 5xx series ?


http://www.mediafire.com/file/s4oc0q60b8e8s69/Ellesmere.rom

specialbkh

I don't know why but you need to patch your driver files in rx570s.
https://www.monitortests.com/forum/Thread-AMD-ATI-Pixel-Clock-Patcher

download patcher from the above.
you just need to run and press yes.

specialbkh

rx 580 4g nitro+
ori : 22mh/s
mod : 27mh/s

I'm gonna go for msi rx 570 cards for rx 500 series.

good luck for everyone!!

Konomi

@specialbkh I mixed 3 of Rx 570 with my flashed Rx 480, and then when I use the patcher, the windows not able to log into windows next time. I guess the patch only work if I use only 570/580 series on 1 rig.

Konomi

@specialbkh what is the temperature of the MSI card after mining for about 1-2 hours?

specialbkh

It's between 60~70 temperature.
The windows can't recognize your rx570s because of driver.

If you flashed rx480 with older driver, then you need to flash the original rom and install lastest crimpson driver 17.4.4 first.

Then you patch your driver and flash your cards.

good luck~

narba88

specialbkh said:

MSI rx 570 4g gaming x
ori : 22mh/s
mod : 28mh/s

Sapphire rx 580 4g pulse
ori : 24mh/s (factory overclocked)
mod : 28mh/s

I will do more test on rx 580 4g nitro+ today

Would you care to share your core clock/Mem freq. on our modded bios?

Konomi

@specialbkh: oh, so the flash also depend on driver version. Thank you for the advice .
Do you mind to look at the nitro 570 that I post above? I got the same value on my 3 cards and have no idea which strap should I copy.

specialbkh

I mostly used
gpu clock : 1090
mem clock: 2040

@Konomi
the 1500 to 2000 is right way.

Konomi

@specialbkh
This bios doesn't look like that.

specialbkh

https://github.com/jaschaknack/PolarisBiosEditor/tree/110aa3a5a0aeafe16bb0a96b53583e7e8e77999b

try this polaris editor

Konomi

@specialbkh Great, thank you very much

EthereumMinereu

Did you found a way to get 6 working?

hamba

Quote from: atanas012 on Today at 06:52:54 PM
Hello All.
I was able to get 6 x RX-500 series running on windows 10 x64. After two days the stupidest thing I tried worked Grin.
1. use DDU to clean the PC from any previous drivers.
2. Disable 4G decoding so you can log into windows (only for Z170,H170, etc.)
3. Extract older driver for RX 400 series in Drive C: (I use 16.9.2 )
4. Extract driver for RX 500 series in Drive C: (I use 17.4.3)
5. Copy and replace all content from "C:\AMD\Non-WHQL-Win10-64Bit-Radeon-Software-Crimson-16.9.2-Sep21\Packages\Drivers\Display\WT6A_INF\B307117" to "C:\AMD\WHQL-Win7-64Bit-Radeon-Software-Crimson-ReLive-17.4.3-Apr17\Packages\Drivers\Display\W76A_INF\B313057" (Basically you copy the old driver over the new)
6. Install the VGA cards manually from Device manager in Windows pointing path to the new driver 17.4.3 in this case.
7. Reboot and enable 4G Decoding in Bios
8. Enjoy if it works for you.

You can try with different driver versions if they work for you. I`m happy whit the 16.9.2 for the moment but any driver that works whit 6 and more RX 400 series GPUs should work Grin.

I know that this solution sound stupid but it`s tested on 8 different rigs whit Asus Prime Z270-P and H270 Motherboards and works like a charm.
I`m pretty sure only handful of files need to be replaced but I don have the time to test more elegant solution.

Sorry for my English and grammar. Grin

From bitcointalk

narba88

I just received 2 MSI 570 Armor OC's. Who wants to take them for a spin. My damn 480 armors have been out performing my 480 Gaming X. this might be worth for someone to tweak as I just paid 165 a card.